Why Does My Icing Taste Like Soap?

Icing is the essential final touch on a cake that brings it from something nice and edible into something remarkable and delicious. Icing is also one of the most fiddly, time-consuming parts of making a cake. So much so that some bakers wouldn’t even consider their cakes finished unless they’d iced them. We all have our pet peeves with baking, and icing is where most home bakers get tripped up.

There are a few reasons why your icing might taste like soap. One possibility is that there is soap residue on your utensils or mixing bowl. Alternatively, the recipe you are using might call for too much baking soda, which can give icing a soapy taste. Finally, if your icing is made with butter, it may taste like soap if it is not whipped enough.

It’s easy to make your icing taste like soap, or spice it up with too much cinnamon or nutmeg. How do you prevent this from happening? With these 5 tips on how to prevent icing from tasting like soap.

Why does my icing taste like soap

If your icing tastes like soap, it’s likely that you’ve over-beaten it, causing the protein in the egg whites to curdle. We’re all guilty of overmixing from time to time, but it’s important to keep your eye on the ball; when your icing is at the right consistency and everything is smooth and silky, stop mixing. If your icing tastes like soap, it’s almost certainly because you’ve beat it for too long. If this happens, it’s best to start again. There are a few other reasons why your icing may taste like soap:

Your recipe contains too much baking soda, which will give your icing a soapy flavor. Most cake and icing recipes call for 1/2 teaspoon per batch of icing.

You’re using too much sugar, or not enough fat in your icing. If you’re estimating the amount of sugar you need, remember that white sugar is denser than brown sugar, so use less white sugar than the amount called for in your recipe.

The vanilla extract you’re using has gone bad. Vanilla extract is usually OK for several months after you open the bottle, but if you’ve had yours for a while, it’s probably time to buy a new bottle.

Use pasteurized egg whites

If you’re baking a cake that requires egg whites, use pasteurized egg whites in your icing rather than fresh, unprocessed egg whites. If you’re not using a recipe that calls for more than two egg whites, keep in mind that one large egg white contains about half a tablespoon of icing sugar, so you don’t want to accidentally add too much extra sugar to your icing by using fresh whites. If you’re not sure whether or not the egg whites you have are fresh, put them in a bowl and add a tablespoon of water. If they float to the top, they’re still fresh; if they sink, they’re old and unsafe to eat.

Don’t skimp on the fat

Fat and sugar are the two most important ingredients in any icing recipe. If you skimp on either, your icing will be too thin, or just not taste as good as it should. But, how do you know how much fat to add? If you’re making a buttercream icing, use the rule of thumb that for every 1 cup of icing sugar, you should add 1/2 cup of butter. For other icings, the rule of thumb is that you should add one third the amount of sugar that’s called for in your recipe. For example, if the recipe asks for 1 1/2 cups of sugar, you should add 2/3 cup of fat.

Sifting is your friend

If you’ve ever made a vanilla buttercream icing and found it’s been flavored with cinnamon or nutmeg, you’re not alone. When you’re creaming butter and sugar together, it’s easy for spices that you’ve ground up for a recipe to go airborne and settle in your icing. When you’re creaming butter and sugar together, it’s best to do so in a stand mixer on a low speed. If you’re mixing by hand, use a wooden spoon, not a metal spoon. If you’re adding vanilla extract or other flavorings to your icing, add them at the end of the mixing process. That way you’ll avoid them getting stuck to the whisk and ending up in your icing.

Measure precisely

If you want a smooth, creamy icing, you need to measure the ingredients precisely. It’s easy to add too much water to your icing and end up with a runny mess that won’t coat your cake evenly or thicken up in time. Again, if you’re making a buttercream icing, it’s best to use a stand mixer, so you can pour in the water with the mixer on a low speed. If you’re making a sugar-syrup icing, you can whisk together the sugar and water in a bowl. But if you’re making a cream cheese icing, make sure you whisk the cream cheese and water together in a separate bowl. In both cases, you don’t want the sugar to be present when you’re adding the cream cheese to avoid it curdling.

Add after-baking flavorings at the end

If you want to add a little extra flavor to your icing, but don’t want it to be flavored with cinnamon, nutmeg, or whatever you’ve used, add the flavorings after you’ve finished making the icing. If you’re adding fresh herbs, add them after you’ve poured the icing into a bowl, as they’re likely to get caught in the whisk and end up in the icing. For baking spices such as cinnamon and nutmeg, add them to your icing toward the end. Sprinkle them in and mix thoroughly with a whisk. If you grind them up in a coffee grinder and add them to your icing, you’ll introduce too much air, which will cause your icing to expand and break.

Conclusion

Icing is the essential final touch on a cake that brings it from something nice and edible into something remarkable and delicious. Icing is also one of the most fiddly, time-consuming parts of making a cake. We all have our pet peeves with baking, and icing is where most home bakers get tripped up. It’s easy to make your icing taste like soap, or spice it up with too much cinnamon or nutmeg. With these 5 tips on how to prevent icing from tasting like soap, you can make sure your cakes are as delicious as they look.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.